US Supreme Court won’t revive lawyer Alan Dershowitz’s case against CNN
US Supreme Court won’t revive lawyer Alan Dershowitz’s case against CNN
By David Thomas
WASHINGTON, June 29 (Reuters) – The U.S. Supreme Court declined on Monday to hear prominent lawyer Alan Dershowitz’s bid to revive his defamation lawsuit against CNN over the network’s coverage of his remarks defending Donald Trump during the president’s first Senate impeachment trial in 2020.
The justices turned away the retired Harvard Law professor’s appeal of a lower court’s ruling throwing out his case against CNN, which is owned by Warner Bros Discovery. In his appeal, Dershowitz had urged the justices to roll back protections against defamation claims that the Supreme Court established in its landmark 1964 ruling in a case called New York Times v. Sullivan.
In Sullivan and subsequent decisions, the Supreme Court said that to win a libel suit, a public figure must demonstrate the offending statement was made with “actual malice,” meaning with knowledge that it was false or with reckless disregard as to whether it was false.
Dershowitz in his petition argued that Sullivan has become “an impregnable fortress that protects media irresponsibility while denying public figures any remedy for egregious misrepresentations.”
Dershowitz was a member of Trump’s defense team in the Senate impeachment trial in 2020 held after the House of Representatives passed articles of impeachment accusing the Republican president of abuse of power and obstruction of Congress. Dershowitz had written a 2018 book arguing against impeaching Trump.
The charges arose from Trump’s attempts to pressure Ukraine to announce an investigation of his Democratic political rival Joe Biden, who went on to defeat Trump in the 2020 presidential election. The Senate voted to acquit Trump, and did so again in his second impeachment trial the following year.
Dershowitz sued CNN over the news outlet’s coverage of his presentation to the Senate during the trial, as he offered an expansive view of presidential power that provoked astonishment among Democrats.
CNN reported that Dershowitz said during Trump’s trial, “if a president does something which he believes will help him get elected in the public interest, that cannot be the kind of quid pro quo that results in an impeachment.” Quid pro quo is a Latin term meaning a favor for a favor.
In his lawsuit, Dershowitz said that this was only part of his remarks, and that CNN repeatedly aired that particular clip to make it seem as if he was “a constitutional scholar and intellectual who had lost his mind.”
CNN argued in filings to the Supreme Court that Sullivan was correctly decided, and that reversing or weakening it as Dershowitz requested could cause “lasting damage to a wide range of precedent.” CNN said it aired Dershowitz’s full remarks and interviewed him on air twice after he complained about the coverage.
A federal judge in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, ruled in favor of CNN in 2023. The Atlanta-based 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals also sided with CNN in 2025, finding that Dershowitz presented no evidence that CNN’s reporters and commentators operated with actual malice.
Dershowitz has earned fame as a trial attorney. He has represented many famous clients including financier Jeffrey Epstein, football star O.J. Simpson, televangelist Jim Bakker, boxer Mike Tyson and WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange.
Conservative Justices Clarence Thomas and Neil Gorsuch have signaled interest in revisiting the Sullivan precedent.
The Supreme Court in recent years turned away opportunities to examine Sullivan, including a 2021 denial that drew dissents from Thomas and Gorsuch. Citing a rapidly changing media environment rife with disinformation, they wrote separately that the court should take a fresh look at its precedents that make it harder for public figures to win defamation cases.
The Supreme Court in 2025 declined to hear an appeal by casino mogul Steve Wynn, who also targeted Sullivan in challenging the dismissal of his defamation lawsuit against the Associated Press.
(Reporting by David Thomas; Editing by Will Dunham)
Clear night skies over Hampshire and Dorset give stunning shots of the Strawberry Moon.
Matthew Beetenson was the sole person involved in a crash in the Peak District in Derbyshire.
The blast was caused by an explosive device which appeared to contain bolts and pellets, the head of Monaco’s government said.
A vehicle crashes through the central reservation on A11 and diversions are put in place.
Suzanne Hall says special red knitted love hearts “meant everything” in her husband’s final days.
With tens of thousands of people still believed missing, teams listen for signs of life beneath the rubble.
By Nellie Peyton DURBAN, South Africa, June 30 (Reuters) – Workers stayed home, shops were shut and buses sat idle across South Africa on Tuesday, as fears mounted that planned anti-immigrant marches
Mark Leeson is helping international search and rescue efforts after two earthquakes
A man holding a “pistol” threatened a female staff member and stole cash said Leicestershire Police.
Police are trying to find Adrian Lewicki, 31, after a woman is raped and assaulted in Nuneaton.
Europe has the oldest population of any continent while also warming the fastest, leading to a dangerous and deadly situation.
The Queen officially opened The Brontë Birthplace in Thornton in May 2025 after a fundraising drive.
Academic staff at Glasgow Caledonian University begin a series of walkouts over plans to cut courses and shed 100 jobs.
Overwhelmed hospitals are racing to save lives in the aftermath of Venezuela’s earthquakes as the stench of decay seeps from collapsed buildings throughout Caracas and families hold onto hope of finding loved ones.
The garden has been created out of scrubland as an oasis for the community to enjoy.
The Alaska Supreme Court ruled Monday that a man with the same name and party as Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan can challenge the sitting lawmaker in the state’s Senate primary in August.
Relatives are desperately searching for their loved ones after a hotel holding more than 100 Venezuelans who were deported by the US on Wednesday collapsed during deadly earthquakes that same evening.
Baylham Care Home’s overall rating improves but it stills need to go further, inspectors say.
Authorities arrested two suspects in connection to a shooting that left a 2-year-old child dead alongside his mother and aunt over the weekend, officials said.
Moor Farm says it was alerted to the fires by neighbours.
Powered by WPeMatico