Trump Administration Claims Executive Privilege Over White House Conversations With Private Advisers (opinion)
Trump Administration Claims Executive Privilege Over White House Conversations With Private Advisers (opinion)
Transparency advocates say it’s the latest attempt to hide more of the executive branch’s business from the public and congressional investigations.
The Justice Department Office of Legal Counsel (OLC) released a memo Monday extending the president’s “executive privilege” to claim confidentiality over White House communications with private advisers.
The memo says the White House can withhold “communications with private advisers so long as the communications relate to official presidential decisionmaking, involve or reflect communications with the President or his direct advisers.”
The new policy would frustrate congressional Democrats’ attempts to investigate the White House if they win back the House in the 2026 midterm elections, which they are favored to do.
The memo also alarmed government watchdog and transparency groups.
“This is the latest attempt by this administration to reduce transparency,” Scott Amey, general counsel for the Project on Government Oversight (POGO), says. “The executive branch has cut resources that ensure public access to government information and taken down information from public websites. It has claimed that the Presidential Records Act is unconstitutional. And now it claims that presidential communications with people outside the government can be shielded as privileged. It’s hard not to read this as anything other than an attempt to gain cover if Congress conducts oversight hearings about the activities and decisions that have been made in the past two years.”
However, the OLC, which advises the attorney general and executive branch on legal matters, wrote that making private advisers’ communications nonconfidential would limit the president’s ability to solicit a wide range of advice.
“Restricting executive privilege to purely intragovernmental communications would foreclose the President from relying on an array of important sources that he may find necessary to the effective discharge of his responsibilities of office,” the OLC opinion said. “Such an outcome not only would impair the President’s Article II functions, but ultimately would harm the public itself.”
The OLC, as a part of the executive branch, frequently concludes that the law supports a more powerful executive.
Executive privilege is the legal principle that certain communications between the president and some senior staff members should be “privileged” and immune to public disclosure through subpoenas of records or staff members. The privilege has been invoked by presidents since George Washington, but its scope and limits have never been firmly defined by the Supreme Court.
In 1977, for instance, the Supreme Court ruled that ex-presidents do retain some right to invoke executive privilege. However, Richard Nixon and Bill Clinton’s attempts to invoke executive privilege in the Watergate and Monica Lewinsky scandals, respectively, were both rejected by federal courts, which have held that executive privilege is not a blanket protection against investigations into the Oval Office.
The Obama White House likewise lost a bid to use executive privilege to withhold records tied to the Fast and Furious scandal from Republican-led congressional committees.
Executive privilege has traditionally not extended to private parties, a point which the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals and U.S. Supreme Court both noted in rulings in 2021 rejecting President Donald Trump’s request to issue an injunction blocking release of presidential documents to Congress related to the January 6 riot.
As George Mason University law professor Ilya Somin wrote at The Volokh Conspiracy in 2022, “Executive privilege would not give Trump the power to restrict the testimony of private citizens.”
“Executive privilege cannot extend to controlling people who aren’t part of the executive branch,” Somin explained. “If President Biden calls me up to discuss some issue (which he should do more often!), he can’t then use executive privilege to keep me from telling Congress about it.”
In any case, the imperial presidency that Trump occupies, and that past administrations worked to make possible, demands more public scrutiny and oversight, not more secrecy and privilege.
The post Trump Administration Claims Executive Privilege Over White House Conversations With Private Advisers appeared first on Reason.com.
The storm cut power to more than 20,000 households and left 7,000 people stranded at Tokyo’s Narita airport.
Thorpe Park station could offer 10-minute trips from east Leeds to the city centre, planners say.
From dawn, people arrived to watch Hull’s famous trawler leave Albert Dock for North End Shipyard.
Memories, photos and memorabilia will be collected to create a documentary, book and exhibitions
Volunteers say they documented about 1,750 species in the grounds of Broughton Sanctuary in Skipton.
Top social media platforms urged the Australian government not to place too much weight on early evidence showing most children still use their products despite a landmark under-16 ban, as lawmakers weigh tougher penalties and investigative powers for regulators. Local heads of YouTube owner Google, Facebook and Instagram owner Meta, Snapchat and TikTok fronted a Senate inquiry as lawmakers pressed them on multiple studies, including from Australia’s internet regulator, showing some 80% of minors were still on social media months after the ban took effect in December.
By Nestor Corrales and Mikhail Flores MANILA, Aug 14 (Reuters) – Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos Jr confirmed on Friday that he would endorse a candidate for the 2028 presidential election, but
By Bernadette Christina and Ananda Teresia JAKARTA, Aug 14 (Reuters) – Indonesian President Prabowo Subianto said on Friday that a new state export firm will monitor key commodity shipments and its
LUGLON, France, Aug 14 (Reuters) – French authorities evacuated 525 villagers after a wildfire broke out in the pine woods of the southwestern Landes region, near an area already devastated by major blazes this summer. The fire, which razed 1,100 hectares (2,700 acres) after it began on Thursday, spread to within 2 km (1.
Avon Valley Salmon says it might delay the project in Downtown, near Salisbury, but not stop it.
By Marissa Davison and Andrew MacAskill CLACTON-ON-SEA, England, Aug 14 (Reuters) – Reform UK leader Nigel Farage won his self-triggered by-election in Clacton on Friday but saw his strategy to
The Reform UK leader won 22,239 votes, saying on social media that the result “speaks for itself”. Count Binface came second with 9,455.
Aug 14 (Reuters) – A wildfire in Croatia driven by strong winds descended on the tourist town of Omis on Friday, forcing hundreds to evacuate and threatening homes and vehicles, local media reported.
The dustbin themed candidate got 9,455 votes and came second to Nigel Farage
Roads are closed and the Army’s Explosive Ordnance Disposal team is called to a property.
Drenching storms rolled over the flood-ravaged Midwest for a sixth day early Friday, bringing more rain to areas where severe flooding has already forced hundreds of people from their homes and left more than 300,000 without power.
Sister Mayela wears her black veil and habit as she walks to work near where another Catholic nun was violently attacked in Jerusalem’s Old City — but she’s now accompanied by a Jewish volunteer for protection. Many Christians in Israel, who make up less than 2% of the country’s population, are worried visible signs of their faith will draw harassment, which has increased as multiple conflicts grip the region. “I’m scared after the sister was beat up,” said Sister Mayela, a Mexican nun who’s lived in Jerusalem on and off for more than two decades.
A review of the front page stories from the daily newspapers in Scotland.
The country’s chief anti-immigrant activist and Brexit architect, Farage was already the member of parliament (MP) for Clacton but resigned from parliament – triggering the by-election – after facing unprecedented scrutiny over his finances
Students stood quietly outside their Bangkok school Friday as teachers checked their bags, pockets and even pencil cases under new security measures introduced after last week’s deadly shooting.Six teachers on Friday morning meticulously searched pupils’ backpacks as they arrived for class, going through every pocket.
Powered by WPeMatico