Defense in Charlie Kirk’s killing say shooter should not get death penalty, hit ‘intended target’
Defense in Charlie Kirk’s killing say shooter should not get death penalty, hit ‘intended target’
The man charged with killing Charlie Kirk shouldn’t get the death penalty because the shooter “hit the intended target” and no one else was endangered when the conservative activist was shot from a rooftop at an event in Utah last year, his lawyers said.
Defendant Tyler Robinson’s attorneys say the bullet traveled above the crowd of several thousand people at Utah Valley University on Sept. 10 and “there were no threats to others.” Whether the shooting endangered the crowd is a key issue: Prosecutors cited the risk that other people could have been harmed as an aggravating factor under state law that makes Kirk’s killing a capital crime.
“The only evidence presented supports that the bullet traveled above, not through, the crowd,” defense attorneys wrote in documents filed late Tuesday as the defense tries to block the case from proceeding to trial.
Prosecutors have said numerous people were within a “zone of danger” around Kirk, where a stray or ricocheting bullet could have hurt anyone close to the victim.
The defense lawyers also disputed claims that Robinson targeted Kirk over his political views. Prosecutors allege Robinson told his roommate that he killed the activist because he “had enough of his hatred.” But the defense said that was not enough to prove what motivated Robinson, after searches of his apartment, computers and telephone failed to produce anything beyond that one statement.
Prosecutors last month during a weeklong hearing presented what they call “overwhelming” evidence against Robinson, including DNA tests that tie him to the suspected murder weapon and apparent confessions by the defendant.
His attorneys questioned the reliability of the DNA tests and other evidence. They didn’t offer any alternative theories for Kirk’s assassination, and made no mention of DNA in Tuesday’s filing.
Robinson is charged with aggravated murder and has not yet entered a plea. He turned himself in a day after Kirk was killed.
His defense attorneys previously tried to get the death penalty taken off the table after prosecutors were found to be in contempt of court for talking about the case to the media. State District Judge Tony Graf rejected that request.
In documents filed last month, prosecutors said the fact that Robinson loaded his rifle with four bullets showed that he knew he could miss Kirk, “thereby putting others in danger.”
But defense attorneys said “it is just as likely that the shooter did not believe he would miss.”
Robinson faces possible sentence enhancements if prosecutors can prove he targeted Kirk because of his politics. They contend that Kirk’s strong opposition to same-sex marriage and gender transitioning stood in contrast to Robinson, who was in a romantic relationship with a roommate, Lance Twiggs. Twiggs told investigators that he had been considering transitioning around the time that Kirk was killed, according to prosecutors.
Twiggs also told investigators that Robinson sometimes talked about politics, including President Donald Trump. Yet Twiggs said he never heard Robinson talk about Kirk before the shooting. The defendant also did not talk much about gender issues or LGBTQ+ rights, Twiggs said. The AP emailed Twiggs’ attorney seeking comment.
Closing arguments in the preliminary hearing are scheduled for Sept. 1. Graf will then decide if the case can go to trial and on what charges. Lawyers for Kirk’s family have asked Graf to make his decision by or on Sept. 1 so the case can proceed.
Prosecutors have until Aug. 18 to respond to the latest defense arguments. The Associated Press left telephone and email messages with the Utah County Attorney’s Office seeking comment.
Preliminary hearings typically don’t last so long. Legal experts said the slow pace reflects a cautious approach by Graf, the large volume of evidence and a desire by prosecutors to disprove conspiracy theories around the case.
By Yi-Chin Lee and Angie Teo TAIPEI, Aug 13 (Reuters) – Air raid sirens rang out and streets emptied in Taiwan’s capital Taipei on Thursday during annual air raid drills that also included the
Trump said Wednesday he wants the U.S. to “KEEP” the key waterway.
Residents are evacuated after a large fire involving five homes in Caerphilly county.
The astronomical phenomenon – the best since 1999 – was captured by camera lenses across Yorkshire.
The outbreak, declared on 15 May, has caused more than 2,000 deaths, with thousands more reported cases.
More than 95% of the Sun was covered by the Moon in Cornwall, while parts of Spain experienced the magic of a total eclipse.
Interviews for a new chief constable for Staffordshire Police are due to take place in October.
A single ticketholder in Illinois won a Powerball jackpot of $1.04 billion Wednesday night, the game says.
It was the first time the Russian leader had visited the Kuril islands, according to state media.
Two former Chinese military servicemen have been arrested in South Korea in separate cases of apparent espionage, involving alleged attempts to surveil South Korean military operations and US forces stationed in the country, police said.
A cloud of dust billows behind Maarten Janse’s tractor as he spreads a mixture of compost, straw and manure over a field to nourish the parched soil. Janse’s farm on the fertile land of the Netherlands’ southwestern Zeeland Province is drying out despite his efforts to make it more drought resistant as accelerated human-caused global warming and a supersized El Nino batter fields across Europe. The drought that is roasting much of Europe this summer is taking a heavy toll on crops across the continent, from potatoes in the Netherlands to corn in Bosnia and grapes in Italy.
President Trump said Wednesday that the U.S. has “total control” over the Strait of Hormuz, writing on social media: “I THINK WE WILL KEEP IT.”
Jacqui Durkin says officers accused of abusing their position for sexual purposes account for 36% of her office’s most serious cases.
Relentless storms that unleashed catastrophic flooding in eastern Indiana are set to reload across the Midwest on Thursday, raising the risk of another round of dangerous flooding from Iowa and northern Illinois into the already inundated Ohio Valley.
For the second time in two months, the ground was shaking in South America. Once again, families flooded social media with pleas for help finding missing loved ones under flattened buildings. Once again, governments across political divides and continents pledged aid.
A witness describes “black smoke” pouring from the roof of Futures House in Luton.
Another record number of students are expected to secure a place at their first choice of university.
With rising tuition fees and living costs, do higher graduate earnings cover the cost of a degree?
Your full guide to A-level results day, including what to do if you are not happy with your grades.
The warning comes as European countries step up efforts to disrupt Russia’s maritime oil trade and its so-called shadow fleet.
Powered by WPeMatico