Supreme Court says Alito’s verbal reaction to Sotomayor was based on a ‘misunderstanding’
Supreme Court says Alito’s verbal reaction to Sotomayor was based on a ‘misunderstanding’
The highly unusual exchange between Justice Samuel Alito and Justice Sonia Sotomayor over a dissent read from the bench was based on a “misunderstanding” by the conservative justice, the Supreme Court said Friday.
“Justice Alito was notified in advance by Justice Sotomayor’s chambers that she would be reading a dissent from the bench,” the court spokesperson said in a statement in response to questions from CNN.
“It was a misunderstanding on Justice Alito’s part,” the spokesperson added.
The rare statement came a day after a tense back-and-forth between the two justices when Sotomayor, the court’s senior liberal, publicly read a dissent in a case involving asylum claims. Alito, a conservative who was then set to summarize the next opinion, appeared taken aback by his colleague’s remarks.
“There’s much that I would have added to my bench statement had I known there would be a dissent read,” Alito said, an unusual break from protocol during what is normally a highly choregraphed release of opinions.
Alito, who authored three of the four opinions released Thursday, suggested at the time that he didn’t realize Sotomayor would read her dissent verbally. Verbal dissents are rare and usually underscore a justice’s strong disagreement with the majority’s opinion.
The back-and-forth came amid signs of strife behind the curtain of the high court as it veers toward its final days of the current term juggling a number of cases involving President Donald Trump and culture war issues. The Alito-Sotomayor exchange came in a case dealing with a policy of turning asylum seekers away at the border, which the conservative majority approved in a 6-3 decision.
The court is set to hand down additional opinions on Monday and is likely to wrap up its term next week.
Earlier this year, it was Sotomayor who had to explain her words. The justice issued an unusual public apology in April after she criticized Justice Brett Kavanaugh for his writing in another immigration case.
Sotomayor’s apology followed remarks she made in Kansas in which she criticized Kavanaugh for his concurring opinion in a high-profile emergency immigration case dealing with ICE patrols.
“I regret my hurtful comments,” Sotomayor said at the time. “I have apologized to my colleague.”
Thursday’s Supreme Court case at issue dealt with a policy called “metering” in which federal agents stationed at the border turn back asylum seekers before they ever step foot on US soil, frustrating their ability to be formally inspected by officials — the first step in a process that could eventually result in them being granted asylum.
The policy was first used during President Barack Obama’s administration but was formalized during Trump’s first term. It is currently not in use. The Supreme Court ruled that, in order to claim asylum, a foreign national must have their feet on US soil.
After Alito quickly summarized his opinion for the court (Alito is often quite brief in his summaries), Sotomayor read a lengthy oral dissent that among other things called attention to the infamous episode of the US turning away a ship of Jewish refugees fleeing Nazi Germany in the 1930s. Hundreds of those refugees were later killed in the Holocaust.
After Sotomayor’s presentation, Alito was set to explain the next opinion. Instead, he continued briefly to discuss the asylum case, noting that it had been used by both a Democratic and Republican administration. He also described the policy at issue in the case as “orderly and humane.”
This story has been updated with additional details.
For more CNN news and newsletters create an account at CNN.com
Emergency services recovered the body from the pool in the park in West Bromwich after she disappeared in the afternoon.
Cambridgeshire Police says a man in his 20s is taken to hospital with serious injuries.
The family of murdered teenager Joshua Hall are welcoming the ban on social media for under 16s.
This national debate was sparked after the death of 18-year-old Henry Nowak.
A round-up of pictures from across the West this week.
Pakistan’s military said Sunday that three members of its paramilitary Rangers force were killed and four others wounded in fighting after militants launched an attack the previous night on a regional headquarters in the southern port city of Karachi. A militant rammed an explosives-laden vehicle into the provincial headquarters of the paramilitary Pakistan Rangers in Karachi on Saturday night, triggering an intense exchange of gunfire with security forces, according to police and witnesses. In a statement, the military said security forces had killed three attackers and captured a fourth, who was wounded.
People share mixed emotions as Durham County Council leaves it brutalist home of 63 years.
Italy’s PM was not long ago being called the “Trump whisperer”, but their relationship has gone from public attacks to personal insults.
The work follows the completion of a major upgrade to Colne bus station earlier this year.
A council calls on National Highways to take responsibility for clearing litter on the A34.
The Japanese Summer Festival is back in Liverpool with activities celebrating the country’s culture.
The houses in Brynteg have seen their prices reduced more than six times over two and a half years.
The Liverpool care home was visibly dirty, with “bad smells” coming from people’s bedding, inspectors say.
Ten years on from Brexit people in Boston share their views on how the town has changed.
Students in Guernsey have made the sculpture which will act as a bin.
Health and Social Care says its compliance challenges are “a result of being under-resourced”.
Salford Cathedral reopens on 4 July after a transformative project.
Rights of Nature could give Lough Neagh the same status as a person, entitled to the same protections.
Michael Nicholson says recovering from his cocaine addiction is the best thing he has ever done.
The wooden bridge in Melton Country Park should be open to the public by the end of summer 2026.
Powered by WPeMatico