Stephen Miller and Pete Hegseth Are Wildly Misleading About Section 702 Warrantless Surveillance (opinion)
Opinion
Stephen Miller and Pete Hegseth Are Wildly Misleading About Section 702 Warrantless Surveillance (opinion)
It has been said that patriotism is the last refuge of the scoundrel—but we might need harsher terms to describe how some prominent figures in the Trump administration are appealing to Congress to extend a warrantless surveillance program that is routinely used to spy on Americans.
Lawmakers who refuse to reauthorize Section 702 of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) are advancing “marxism” and reversing “patriotic reform,” argued Stephen Miller, the White House deputy chief of staff, in a post on Twitter.
“A libertarian demand to make SecWar get approval from liberal DC judges (the ones who targeted Trump) is madness,” Miller wrote in a separate post.
What has Miller in such a tizzy? On Friday, a bipartisan group of senators (including seven Republicans) blocked the renewal of Section 702 in response to President Donald Trump’s nomination of Bill Pulte to be the new director of national intelligence. Without congressional approval on an extension, those spying powers will expire on June 12.
With reauthorization uncertain, Trump—who used to oppose the reauthorization of federal warrantless spying powers—and the rest of the White House are pulling out all the stops. “America faces real threats from foreign adversaries, terrorists, cyber actors, and hostile intelligence services,” wrote Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth in his own Twitter post about the reauthorization fight. “Section 702 remains one of our nation’s most effective tools for identifying and disrupting those threats before they reach our shores.”
Both Miller and Hegseth are misleading about what Section 702 does and what critics of the program would like to see.
Though it has always been justified as a national security program aimed at spying on foreigners, Section 702 allows for the warrantless collection of Americans’ emails, text messages, phone calls, and other electronic communications. There are few practical limits on how the FBI, CIA, and other intelligence agencies can use the Section 701 database. The program has been used to spy on the communications of protestors, members of Congress, journalists, and more.
And despite how the latest renewal effort in Congress has been branded, civil libertarian groups say the bill actually expands the government’s spying powers rather than constraining them.
“The bill is packed with provisions to create the impression of reform, but it is carefully designed to preserve the status quo regarding warrantless access to Americans’ communications,” warns the Brennan Center for Justice. “Even more alarming, it would make it easier for the government to use Section 702-acquired information against Americans in court. The proposal creates no limits on backdoor searches, let alone a warrant requirement.”
The three-year extension of Section 702 that passed the House in April did not include a requirement that intelligence and law enforcement agencies get a warrant before accessing the Section 702 database. That should be the bare minimum for surveillance reform. Instead, Congress and the Trump administration seem to be moving in the other direction.
In a letter to Congress sent earlier this month, the Electronic Privacy Information Center (EPIC) wrote that its coalition members were “deeply concerned by recent efforts to reauthorize Section 702 without meaningful improvements to protect Americans from warrantless surveillance, or even allow votes on such reforms.”
Contra Miller, this is not “madness,” and the “libertarian demand” here is, simply, that the government abide by the Fourth Amendment and respect the privacy rights of all Americans. Opposition to warrantless surveillance is not “Marxism” or some sort of conspiracy to undermine the country.
That argument isn’t even working on Twitter, where Miller’s posts have been slapped with a community note. It certainly should not convince anyone in Congress, where lawmakers should demand a strict warrant requirement (at a minimum) before extending Section 702.
The post Stephen Miller and Pete Hegseth Are Wildly Misleading About Section 702 Warrantless Surveillance appeared first on Reason.com.
“We’re trying to finish it up,” Trump told ABC News on Monday.
Trinity College in Loughborough closed in 2022 with just 14 pupils on its roll.
Dozens of people are dead and hundreds more injured following an earthquake in the country’s south.
Teacher Gary Day-Davies, 55, targeted his victim both at the school where he taught and at his home.
The catcalls came after ticketholders faced airport-style security to enter the venue at Madison Square Garden.
The Conservative leader will argue that the rules have become a “minefield that exposes almost every significant public decision to legal challenge”.
Iran and Israel declare a halt to fighting as President Trump says both are seeking an “immediate ceasefire” after a major escalation in the 101-day war.
By Panu Wongcha-um BANGKOK, June 9 (Reuters) – More than 5,500 Myanmar refugees living in camps along Thailand’s border have found jobs since Bangkok eased employment curbs last year, an approach that
Police attended an incident Kinnaird Avenue following a report made shortly after 22:30 GMT on Monday 8 June.
Israel’s PM says his country is holding fire “at the moment”, after Iran’s armed forces said they had stopped military action.
At least 100 people have died from Ebola less than a month after authorities declared an outbreak of the disease in eastern Congo, authorities said. Attacks on health workers from angry residents, skepticism among some locals and armed conflict in hot spots continue to challenge efforts to stop the spread. The latest Ebola disease outbreak is caused by the rare Bundibugyo virus, which does not have an approved vaccine or treatment unlike the Zaire virus responsible for most of Congo’s past 16 outbreaks of the disease.
Iran appears emboldened by the outcome and its leaders may sense Trump’s appetite for risk is low.
The council wants to simplify the A140 junction at Earl Stonham with the A1120.
TAIPEI, June 9 (Reuters) – Chinese coast guard ships operating around Taiwan in recent days have been “harassing” commercial shipping by asking them information about their point of origin and
Swiss business leaders and unions are mobilising ahead of a vote Sunday on capping immigration, which has triggered fears of dire impacts on employment and trade relations with the European Union.Major employers’ organisations and unions have dubbed it the “chaos initiative”.
Seven Georgian nationals will be tried in Paris starting Tuesday for the theft of rare editions of Russian literary classics from prestigious French libraries, including works by Alexander Pushkin.The thefts targeted rare Russian classics worth millions of euros in total, including by 19th-century literary greats Pushkin and Nikolai Gogol.
Beagle 2 reached the surface in 2003, but it was not known until 2015, a professor says.
The town council says the rodent has returned to Batford Springs after 40 years.
By Heejin Kim and Josh Arslan SEOUL/BEIJING, June 9 (Reuters) – North Korean leader Kim Jong Un and China’s Xi Jinping agreed to expand cooperation in the areas of politics, economy and culture at a
By Colleen Howe BEIJING, June 9 (Reuters) – The U.S. has added some of the world’s largest solar and battery manufacturers to a list of companies it believes are aiding China’s military.
Powered by WPeMatico