Shroud of Turin, claimed to be Jesus’ burial cloth, contaminated with carrot and red coral DNA
Shroud of Turin, claimed to be Jesus’ burial cloth, contaminated with carrot and red coral DNA
When you buy through links on our articles, Future and its syndication partners may earn a commission.
The Shroud of Turin, which some people claim is Jesus’ burial cloth, contains the DNA of multiple people, along with a huge array of other species, including carrots, melons and red coral.
Some of the DNA traces suggest there’s an influence from India, which could mean the cloth originated there, researchers argue in a new study.
However, there was a notable absence of species traditionally associated with the Levant region and stories in the Bible. What’s more, some of the plant species detected on the shroud did not arrive in the Old World until the 16th century, which suggests the shroud was contaminated centuries later, experts told Live Science.
Overall, the scientific evidence still firmly supports arguments that the Shroud of Turin is a medieval fake, they said.
Likely a fake
The famous shroud has moved around Europe for centuries, but the first documented mention of the shroud was in Lirey, a village in northern France in 1354, and even then, there were debates about whether it was an authentic relic from the crucifixion. The rectangular cloth measures 14.4 by 3.6 feet (4.4 by 1.1 meters) and bears the faint image of a man and numerous stains, some of which are claimed to be blood.
The most robust evidence for the shroud’s age comes from a carbon-dating analysis carried out in 1989, which placed the shroud’s creation between 1260 and 1390, firmly in the medieval period. And last year, work revealed that the human image on the shroud probably resulted from the cloth being laid on a low-relief sculpture.
Some Christian scholars still believe the shroud is genuine and dates back 2,000 years. Yet there is no evidence that the multishaft looms required to manufacture the type of cloth in the shroud existed in Europe, India or the Levant region 2,000 years ago.
“These structures need a loom with four shafts that was invented in the Middle Ages [in Europe],” Andrea Nicolotti, a historian at the University of Turin who wasn’t involved in the work, told Live Science.
Analyzing the DNA
In 2015, Gianni Barcaccia, a professor of genetics and genomics at the University of Padova in Italy, and his colleagues suggested that the Shroud of Turin may have been made in India, based on a genetic analysis of samples collected from the shroud in 1978.
More powerful genomics techniques are available now, so Barcaccia and his colleagues did a new DNA and metagenomic analysis on the samples from 1978 to determine which species any traces of DNA came from. The research was posted to the preprint server bioRxiv March 22 and has not been peer-reviewed yet.
The researchers found human DNA that seems to have come from multiple people, one of whom was the person who collected the samples in 1978. Bacterial species accounted for 10% to 31% of the DNA. Barcaccia’s team noted the presence of DNA from Mediterranean red coral (Corallium rubrum), which suggests “Mediterranean origins or transit through Mediterranean regions.”
Even if the coral came from a particular place, however, it doesn’t mean the shroud was there, too, Nicolotti noted. “Red coral perhaps makes people think of the sea of Palestine,” he said, adding that there was a much more likely scenario for how coral ended up on the shroud. “It makes me think of the coral crucifixes and rosaries, or reliquaries that we know were placed in contact with the cloth.”
Barcaccia’s team found that cats and dogs accounted for about 44% of the animal DNA, but there were also traces from chickens, cattle, goats, sheep, pigs, horses, deer and rabbits. In addition, there were slight traces of skin mites, ticks and an assortment of fish.
We are confident that this diversity of animal and plant species identified highlights the significant environmental contamination of the shroud that likely occurred in recent centuries, particularly following the voyages of Marco Polo and Christopher Columbus
Gianni Barcaccia, professor of genetics and genomics at the University of Padova in Italy
Plants species were richly represented too. Carrot DNA provided about 31% of the plant DNA. But there was also DNA from wheat, maize, rye, peppers, tomatoes, potatoes, melons or cucumbers, and peanuts, as well as traces of grasses, bananas, almonds, walnuts and oranges.
Some of these plants may reflect typical agricultural practices in Europe and the Mediterranean, the study authors wrote, but some of those plants, such as bananas, potatoes, peppers and tomatoes, were introduced to Europe mainly from the Americas in the 16th century and later. And the carrot DNA is genetically similar to cultivars bred from orange carrots originally grown in Western Europe between the 15th and 16th centuries, which suggests relatively recent contamination, Barcaccia told Live Science via email.
“We are confident that this diversity of animal and plant species identified highlights the significant environmental contamination of the shroud that likely occurred in recent centuries, particularly following the voyages of Marco Polo and Christopher Columbus,” he said.
Notably, some species historically associated with the Mediterranean region were lacking.
“The vast range of animal and plant material doesn’t seem indicative of any particular environment, but I note the absence of olives, dates, pomegranates, camels and of course myrrh and aloes,” Hugh Farey, an independent researcher who runs a blog called The Medieval Shroud and wasn’t involved in the work, told Live Science via email.
I try to imagine how many people must have touched the shroud, all the instruments used by the American scholars in 1978, and even who may have touched and made the brushes that were used to dust the shroud periodically,
Andrea Nicolotti, historian at the University of Turin
Human DNA can be transferred to an object with or without touch, and it’s the same with DNA from other animals and plants, so many traces may have ended up on the shroud due to its public displays in medieval cities. “All the vegetables make me think of the market that is 100 meters [330 feet] from the square where public exhibitions were held for centuries in Turin, or of the dust of Chambéry when the Shroud used to be displayed along a tree-lined avenue,” Nicolotti said.
The researchers dated a couple of threads in the shroud, one to between 1451 and 1622 and the other to between 1642 and 1800. These dates align with when the shroud was repaired in 1534, not long after it was damaged by fire, and in further conservation work in 1694, the team noted.
Importantly, none of the new findings contradict the definitive carbon-dating analysis carried out in 1989, Nicolotti said.
RELATED STORIES
—Shroud of Turin wasn’t laid on Jesus’ body, but rather a sculpture, modeling study suggests
—When was Jesus born?
—Reliquary of the Holy Crib: Remains of Jesus’ manger from Bethlehem
However, what’s more controversial is Barcaccia and colleagues’ interpretation that nearly 40% of the human DNA found on the shroud is from Indian lineages, suggesting “the possibility that the yarn was produced in India.”
Nicolotti doesn’t think the shroud is likely to have come from India and remains convinced it is a forgery originating in medieval Europe as the carbon dating from 1989 implies. He is also not surprised that a range of human DNA was found on the cloth.
“I try to imagine how many people must have touched the shroud, all the instruments used by the American scholars in 1978, and even who may have touched and made the brushes that were used to dust the shroud periodically,” he said.
Michigan faces UConn in the national championship game Monday night. Here’s how to watch live.
The NCAA basketball madness concludes on Monday with the championship game. Here’s how to tune in.
We tested over a dozen different compression packing cubes to find the best ones to help you pack smarter and save space on your next trip.
Our fashion writer scrolled through the secret storefront and rounded up the best of the bunch, all under $50.
This week’s best bundles and discounts are just a click away!
Also on my radar: Beats earbuds slashed by over 40% and a Black & Decker Dustbuster for just $25, to name a couple.
From a joint-saving kneeler to the best pruner, this is the gear that’s worth your green, shoppers say.
We tested 13 units to find the best air purifiers for allergies, pet odor and smoke. From splurge-worthy picks to budget-friendly standouts, we found that cleaner air doesn’t have to come at a high price.
Celebs swear by them, but these experts say there’s a science behind finding the ones that really work.
Open-toed shoe season is right around the corner — here’s how to get rough heels and arches buffed and smooth as the weather heats up.
Personal trainers, marathon runners and competitive athletes put 23 wearables to the test — this is the best fitness tracker we found.
We tested tools from brands like Weber, GrillArt and Scrub Daddy so you can get your grates gleaming before your next barbecue.
Keep food and drinks cold for hours with these reusable options from brands like Yeti, Hydro Flask and Arctic Ice.
While the Air just hit its best price ever, only some of Apple’s tablet lineup is seeing noteworthy discounts.
Tired of removing heavy frames from your wall? Grab one of these digital frames so you can easily change the image from your phone.
From lightweight linen sets to denim duos, consider this your definitive guide to the chic, low-effort co-ords defining the season.
The ultralight, sleek laptop features a stunning 13.6-inch screen and the wicked-fast M5 chip — get a rare $149 off.
If you want to switch things up, try these five other timeless styles, from $17.
These heart-shaped waffles are a staple in Norway and Sweden, and they might just become your new favorite Saturday morning treat.
The new M5 Air just saw a giant price drop, but not every model is a good deal — and one is a great buy even not on sale.
This dentist-loved, 120,000+ fan-approved, gum-saving gadget blasts plaque and freshens your mouth.
We tested every major bronzer under the sun to find our top pick — and (surprise?) it’s from Lady Gaga’s makeup line.
Ready for some rollbacks? We dug up deep discounts on HP, Stanley, Samsung, Skechers and more mega-faves.
If you’re deficient in magnesium, you may struggle with sleep or anxiety, or you may experience other symptoms like migraines or muscle spasms. These high-quality, dietitian-approved supplements could help bolster your overall health.
Have a spring to-do list you need to sort? Amazon has everything from vacuums and cookware to clothing discounted by up to 70% right now.
Powered by WPeMatico






_9934.png)
_9934.png)


_9728.png)
_9728.png)

